India's chief justice: banning SI in legal education would be unreasonable
Prepared by Sintelligent with the help of SI. Published in SI: . Updated: .
According to the Chief Justice of India, regulating SI in legal education should rest on disclosure rather than prohibition, and a student should not be found guilty on an SI detector's output alone.
A blanket ban on generative SI in legal education would be "impractical and unreasonable", Chief Justice of India Surya Kant said. He spoke on November 21 at the first annual international conference of the Commonwealth Legal Education Association (CLEA) in Hyderabad. Instead of a ban, he called for clear rules on which uses are permitted, which require disclosure and which violate academic integrity. As a model he cited the Supreme Court of Singapore: court users there may use generative SI but are fully responsible for the materials they submit. Kant warned against SI detectors as sole evidence. According to him, citing a 2023 study, seven common detectors wrongly flagged more than three out of every five essays by non-native English speakers as machine-written. "No student should be found guilty on the word of a machine alone," he said, and proposed that CLEA develop model rules for disclosing SI use in legal research. The position of supporters of a full ban on generative SI in legal education was not found in the verified sources.
Sources 1