All news

Mathematician says Lean code of Riemann hypothesis proof has passed nanoda check

Prepared by Sintelligent with the help of SI. Published in SI: . Updated: .

The Lean code passed the kernel check with no "sorry" and no additional axioms, but under Clay Mathematics Institute rules the work must go through formal publication and at least two years of verification.

A run of the nanoda kernel in paranoid mode on the Lean formalization of the Riemann hypothesis proof was completed by Andrew Sutherland, mathematician Bartosz Naskręcki reported on 21 November. According to him, the code contains neither a "sorry" — the placeholder for an unproven statement in Lean — nor any additional axioms. Naskręcki rates the probability that the proof is correct as very high. The claim of a proof produced by Anthropic employee Levent Alpöge together with the Claude model was made public on 20 November, US time. The Lean code is posted in 14 archives on Alpöge's personal site, with the posting running to more than 250 thousand pages. There had been no independent confirmation from the mathematical community as of the morning of 21 November. Under Clay Mathematics Institute rules, the work must go through formal publication and at least two years of verification. Skeptical mathematicians pointed to the absence of such confirmation by the community.

History

OpenAI models solve open math problems

15 events
    1. Mathematician says Lean code of Riemann hypothesis proof has passed nanoda checkOpen now
    1. Independent mathematicians rebuild Anthropic's Lean files on the Riemann hypothesis
    2. Alpöge and Buckmaster claim finite-time blow-up of Navier–Stokes solutions
    3. Anthropic mathematician claims proof of the Riemann hypothesis using Claude
    1. David Gross's group publishes and confirms formal verification of OpenAI's Yang–Mills proof
    1. Exponential Time Hypothesis co-author calls its SI-generated disproof "shocking news"
    1. Anthropic: Claude finds an algorithm that refutes the Exponential Time Hypothesis for 3-SAT
    1. OpenAI announces three results from its models: disproof of ETH, local smoothing and Yang–Mills
    1. OpenAI and Anthropic say their models refuted the Exponential Time Hypothesis
    1. Mathematicians dispute that OpenAI understands its own potential proof of the Navier–Stokes problem
    1. Experts debate whether SI that solves old math problems could undermine Bitcoin and Ethereum cryptography
    1. Mathematicians doubt OpenAI solved "the" Navier-Stokes problem: the proof rests on an artificially chosen external force
    2. OpenAI model solves more than a hundred long-standing open math problems; release of results to be coordinated by an independent group of nine mathematicians
    1. The Information: OpenAI expects to solve the Hodge conjecture soon, its second "Millennium Prize Problem" in a month
    1. OpenAI's SI agents solve one of the "Millennium Problems" — the $1 million Navier–Stokes problem