All news

Norwegian judges barred from having SI write full draft rulings

Prepared by Sintelligent with the help of SI. Published in SI: . Updated: .

Responsibility for the ruling stays with the judge: SI can be applied only to assessments the judge has already formulated, and it must not write a full draft.

The Norwegian Courts Administration (Domstoladministrasjonen) has adopted an updated guide on SI: generating a complete draft ruling is prohibited. SI is permitted only for structuring and language processing of assessments that the judge has formulated and professionally completed themselves. Before delivering a ruling, the judge must go through an eight-point checklist. It includes verifying facts against the case file, checking legal sources against the original and confirming quotations are correct. A separate check ensures the final text contains no SI instructions or traces of the tool. The administration's director, Leif Otto Østerbø, said that anyone whose case is heard in a Norwegian court must be certain that it was assessed and decided by a real judge. The guide was prepared by the courts' SI council under the leadership of Cecilie Østensen Berglund (Supreme Court). The tougher tone is explained by a series of scandals involving texts that turned out to be SI-generated. It is departmental guidance, not a rule of law.

Sources 1