US Justice Department adds Pangram SI-detector findings on defense filings to the case
Prepared by Sintelligent with the help of SI. Published in SI: . Updated: .
In the Northern District of Texas, lawyers are required to disclose the use of generative SI, and Pangram's results are being attached to the case as an argument against the defense.
In the case over non-citizen voting against Halvinder Bhengura, US Justice Department prosecutors ran the defense's procedural filings through Pangram and attached the results to their arguments. They told the court that the case had turned into "defense by ChatGPT" and the motions into "AI slop" (carelessly generated text). Attorneys Nicole Knox and Mario Herrera told 404 Media that they had disclosed the use of generative SI under a new district rule on mandatory disclosure. Herrera said he prepared the federal trial in four days while the lead attorney was in hospital. Judge Mark Pittman criticized the defense for "superficially persuasive but fundamentally unsound arguments, clearly generated by SI." The Pangram results were mixed and did not show 100% SI authorship. Pangram CEO Max Spero told 404 Media that more often the service is used inside law firms to check the work of junior lawyers.
Sources 1