All news

Ukraine's Supreme Court returns lawyer's cassation appeal that cited four nonexistent court rulings

Prepared by Sintelligent with the help of SI. Published in SI: . Updated: .

An unverified citation of a nonexistent court ruling led to the cassation appeal being returned; the court restored the deadline only after the defects were remedied and held that checking citations remains the responsibility of the parties to the proceedings.

By a ruling dated 26 March 2026 in case No. 523/9632/24 (a dispute over a father's participation in raising his son), Ukraine's Supreme Court returned a cassation appeal: the lawyer cited four rulings (No. 522/19197/15, No. 761/26645/16-с, No. 753/12866/17, No. 686/15262/17) that were never issued by either the Supreme Court or Ukraine's Supreme Court and concerned other categories of disputes. The court said it had no objection to the use of SI tools in preparing procedural documents, but placed on participants the duty to verify that decisions exist, that case numbers are correct and that legal conclusions match the circumstances of the dispute. After the defects were remedied, the lawyer filed the appeal again, and the court restored the deadline and opened cassation proceedings.

Sources 1

History

Fabricated SI court filings in courts across countries

3 events
  1. Ukraine's Supreme Court returns lawyer's cassation appeal that cited four nonexistent court rulingsOpen now
  2. Arizona court unable to establish grounds for arrest because of a police report written with SI
  3. About 80% of South Korean judges encounter SI-fabricated legal precedents